3. How do we compare to
other sword-fighting groups? What alternatives exist?
There are a number of different options for swordfighting in Ottawa - if you know of any that I don't know about - let me know and I'll include them.
There are a number of different options for swordfighting in Ottawa - if you know of any that I don't know about - let me know and I'll include them.
Caldrithig SCA Heavy Rapier and Historical Swordfighting (i.e. our group):
Participation costs are low and flexible (somewhere around $2 per session). When we compromise on the historical accuracy of techniques/equipment, it is motivated only by safety. Our focus is on historical accuracy and casual learning over competition which leads to a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. See: 4. What to expect at your first practice? or see Caldrithig Rapier and Historical Swordfighting
Participation costs are low and flexible (somewhere around $2 per session). When we compromise on the historical accuracy of techniques/equipment, it is motivated only by safety. Our focus is on historical accuracy and casual learning over competition which leads to a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. See: 4. What to expect at your first practice? or see Caldrithig Rapier and Historical Swordfighting
SCA Armoured Combat (Rattan):
The Society for Creative Anachronism also offers armoured fighting using wooden sticks and heavy body armour. The weapons used tend to be cheaper, but the armour is more expensive. Injury risks are slightly increased, and physical strength is more important than in what we do. Armoured Combat is more closely integrated into the SCA, and has a deeper history within it. See: Caldrithig Armoured Combat
The Society for Creative Anachronism also offers armoured fighting using wooden sticks and heavy body armour. The weapons used tend to be cheaper, but the armour is more expensive. Injury risks are slightly increased, and physical strength is more important than in what we do. Armoured Combat is more closely integrated into the SCA, and has a deeper history within it. See: Caldrithig Armoured Combat
Historical European Martial Arts (HEMA/WMA) / Ottawa Swordplay:
There are a variety of other groups who are dedicated to reconstructing historical sword-fighting techniques. These groups use a variety of different standards of equipment and training. They often use stiffer swords than we allow and use riskier historical techniques. This is usually made possible through a requirement for higher training before being allowed to fight. Such groups provide the highest quality instruction, and take a more serious martial-arts attitude to the sport. The cost of lessons often elevates the participation price to be similar to that of other professionally taught martial arts courses. See: http://ottawaswordplay.com/
Shastara Vidiyā (Traditional Indian martial arts):
Training is comprehensive, involving everything from footwork to wrestling to sword-fighting skills. Sword use remained popular in India more recently than in Europe. Compared to modern European techniques, parrying with the edge of the weapon is avoided in favour of shields, and there is a focus on cultivating mobility and misleading the opponent. The local group is very welcoming. It works on a model where participation is free, but long term members are expected to absorb a share of the costs of operation. If you are interested – let me know and I can put you in touch (I can be contacted through the blog form).
Classical (Olympic) Fencing:
Group memberships are often expensive, running into about $200 per year. Sword-fighting techniques are derived from the last swords used in the 18th century (small-swords and coliche-marde's), meaning that there is much less variety. The weapons used are lighter weight and less historically accurate. However, the opportunities for competitive play are far greater.
Boffer Live Action Role Playing groups (e.g. Amtgard):
These groups use foam or padded weapons and minimal armour. Costs to participate are very low. However, the ability to recreate historical techniques is quite limited. Many of these groups add interest by bringing in rules from role-playing games, leveling up, and use of magic etc.
Classical (Olympic) Fencing:
Group memberships are often expensive, running into about $200 per year. Sword-fighting techniques are derived from the last swords used in the 18th century (small-swords and coliche-marde's), meaning that there is much less variety. The weapons used are lighter weight and less historically accurate. However, the opportunities for competitive play are far greater.
Boffer Live Action Role Playing groups (e.g. Amtgard):
These groups use foam or padded weapons and minimal armour. Costs to participate are very low. However, the ability to recreate historical techniques is quite limited. Many of these groups add interest by bringing in rules from role-playing games, leveling up, and use of magic etc.
This publication is not a corporate publication of the SCA Inc., nor does it delineate SCA policies. This document is intended for informational purposes only, and was created by its author without authorisation with the intent of promoting and sharing an interest.
No comments:
Post a Comment